By Jon Preshaw
This GAAR panel ruling can’t have been a surprise to anyone. However, I can’t really see any basis on which the transactions could realistically have escaped Part 7A anyway. The GAAR appears to have been applied in advance of a ‘normal’ assessment and appeal process, and other users of the arrangements can now expect swift follow up and, one assumes, threats of GAAR penalties where the timing supports it. I wonder if a similar approach might be taken to other post-2011 disguised remuneration structures which have not yet reached tribunal? Something to look out for after 30 September!
Generally though, given this approach to disguised remuneration (or non-remuneration?), is it really now necessary to have swathes of impossibly complex rules addressing these issues? Part 7A now runs to more than 60 individual sections, before even beginning to consider the numerous amendments dotted around in Finance Acts. For the sake of tax advisers everywhere, is it now time to look at simplifying Part 7A?
Generally though, given this approach to disguised remuneration (or non-remuneration?), is it really now necessary to have swathes of impossibly complex rules addressing these issues? Part 7A now runs to more than 60 individual sections, before even beginning to consider the numerous amendments dotted around in Finance Acts. For the sake of tax advisers everywhere, is it now time to look at simplifying Part 7A?
Tax Disputes and Investigations – March 2026
In this edition, we cover a range of significant developments in UK tax disputes and investigations. We share our recent experience on MTIC and HMRC internal reviews, and analyse the First-tier Tribunal's striking findings in HMRC v Harte, where HMRC’s approach to...
Code of Practice 9 (COP9)
Receiving a Code of Practice 9 (COP9) letter from HMRC is a serious matter that requires immediate attention. This letter indicates that HMRC suspects deliberate tax fraud has taken place and initiates a formal investigation. How you respond in the coming weeks can...
Tax Disputes and Investigations – December 2025
This newsletter picks up a number of issues which arose from the November budget which will be of particular interest to those involved in tax disputes. Additionally, we have focussed on some new ‘Guidelines for Compliance’...
Tax Disputes and Investigations – July 2025
HMRC reactivates enquiries into unallowable purpose Ben Proctor HMRC has been writing to taxpayers with open enquiries involving the unallowable purpose rule at Section 441 CTA 2009. The letters invite taxpayers to reconsider their position in light of three Court of...